Mayfair New York Hotel

Anonymous guest from Atlanta, GA US stayed on November 15, 2004

"Room very small, but quiet. The one small elevator required patience."

Recommends the hotel to others? Yes

Chris from Jackson, MS US stayed on February 16, 2004

"First room I received had a problem...I had a new room within minutes"

Recommends the hotel to others? Yes

Jan from San Fran, CA US stayed on December 22, 2003

"This hotel was described as a "3" star hotel, and it most certainly was not! It was so poor I did not stay one night, & expect to be fully reinbursed! It was a third class hotel, & I deeply recented the upset of starting my holiday with the stress of having to make other arrangements at night, in the middle of "high" season. Jan Small"

Recommends the hotel to others? No

Melissa from Fort Worth, TX US stayed on December 06, 2003

"The Mayfair Hotel could not be in a better location! It is steps away from Broadway, Rockefeller Center and Times Square. The rooms are tiny but have everything you would need while visiting NYC. The staff is very helpful too. We would stay there again and again and highly recommend it!"

Recommends the hotel to others? Yes

Carol from Bangor, ME US stayed on November 10, 2003

"Here were some of the problems: - unrepaired holes in the ceiling were the last thing I saw each night - dust and grime, so I couldn't put any of my clothes on the closet shelf or windowsill, although the sheets were clean and housekeeping took good care of the bathroom - bad water pressure, but plenty of hot water - clock/alarm clock didn't work - barely enough room to turn around; internet picture made room look bigger than it was - lumpy mattress; lumpy pillows - no thermostat control - I was cold! - the price of the room should have been at least $25 less per night, especially compared to similar hotels However: the staff was very friendly and helpful at all times"

Recommends the hotel to others? No

Sara from Plantation, FL US stayed on November 03, 2003

"The bathroom had some mildew. That is a turnoff. A little bleach does wonders. More care when the painters do touch-ups. Paint down the side of the mirror is sloppy work. Being able to get ice myself would have been much better than having to call the desk and wait and wait. Even a small room like mine is expensive and the details DO make a difference. Better quality sheets would be nice too. Paper thin is not my kind of sheet. And finally, I really hate thin pillows. They were great about giving me 2 extra ones. So you see there were some good things and some turnoffs that could be fixed with just a little more caring attention........"

Recommends the hotel to others? Yes

Anonymous guest from Old Bridge, NJ US stayed on October 23, 2003

"The rooms are very, very tiny, looks like a dorm room, plain white, no color or pictures to it. Shower didnt have hot water or any water pressure."

Recommends the hotel to others? No

Anonymous guest from Orem, UT US stayed on October 23, 2003

"Maid took expensive shampoo from room, front desk did nothing about it. Hotel management was very reluctant to help with any special requests, even rude at times."

Recommends the hotel to others? No

Lance from Orem, UT US stayed on October 23, 2003

"The staff of the hotel was not helpful in the least to accomodate our needs. On the last day, we finally spoke to the owner of the property because we were so frustrated. He was then willing to accomodate us, but it was too little too late."

Recommends the hotel to others? No