Ramada Plaza & Inn New Yorker Hotel

George from Mesa, AZ US stayed on January 01, 2004

"Best deal in Mid Town Manhatten; A sure winner."

Recommends the hotel to others? Yes

Bernard from Meath, IE stayed on December 09, 2003

"The location was very good but the rooms felt dirty and old carpets on the floors in all the landings and in the rooms."

Recommends the hotel to others? No

Debbie from Essex, GB stayed on December 09, 2003

"I found the hotel very shabby in the halls and dingy. The rooms were very small and not similar to the description on the internet site. There were 14 people in our party and a few of them had to change rooms immediately, as theirs were filthy when they arrived. I also got a non-smoking room when a smoking room was requested and booked. On one day, we had a very large cockroach in the bathroom and it took around 35 minutes for someone to come and tend to it. That is not something I expect to find in my hotel room in New York and obviously speaks volumes about the cleanliness of your hotel. I also asked one day for an urgent message to be put under the door of my room for my friend, as I was out of the hotel and needed to contact her immediately. When I returned, I found that the message had not been left with her and was at the front desk instead, causing some confusion. On the plus side, the location was very good and the 24 diner was a great advantage. Don't think I would ever go back there again though."

Recommends the hotel to others? No

Mark from Stoke On Trent, GB stayed on October 29, 2003

"Room keys only worked periodically. Coffee facilities in the room would have been great. Divergence of quality of staff service levels ranging from offhand to superb."

Recommends the hotel to others? No